The NCAA is taking its sweet time to approve the Jeremiah Masoli transfer waiver *UPDATED*
August 31, 2010 by
John Stansberry
The NCAA loves to take it sweet time on determining whether or not student athletes get cleared to play. The instances of college football’s governing body waiting until the 11th hour (or later) to pass judgment are too countless to review here.
But in the case of Jeremiah Masoli’s transfer to Ole Miss, the delay is pretty damn curious to me. Why the hell is the NCAA taking so long to approve this transfer request?

Masoli in a past life
To recap, Masoli has already graduated from Oregon with a year of eligibility remaining. Under the NCAA’s current set of rules, such an individual can transfer and play immediately at another school so long as the athlete in question enrolls in a graduate program not offered at the school he or she just left. Alabama hoops player Justin Knox made essentially the same kind of transfer earlier this summer and will play his final season at North Carolina.
If I’m missing something or totally misinterpreting the rule then please, somebody get me up to speed here. In my mind there shouldn’t be anything in the academic realm to review. The diploma in Masoli’s hand makes that a moot point.
He’s been accepted at Ole Miss and he’s been practicing with the team. Hell, if the school already has him on board, the problem wouldn’t appear to be on that end, either.
I’m thinking that either the notoriously slow NCAA has one hell of a backlog of cases to review or they’re trying to make a point here. It’s probably a little bit of both.
Masoli is no saint, that’s a given. And he’s not entirely in the clear in regard to the traffic/possession charges in June that forced Oregon to kick him off the team.
So I’m not defending the guy’s propensity for knuckleheadedness, because that’s well established. But I can’t find anything in the NCAA’s rule book saying that someone in Masoli’s position should be denied a transfer request based on previous brushes with the law.
If the NCAA is dragging its feet as a way of showing its dissatisfaction with the situation, then I have a real problem with that. I’d like to think that they’re above that kind of passive-aggressive behavior.
Maybe the NCAA is taking its cue from members of the media, a good many of whom have expressed a negative view on the Masoli transfer. For example, here’s Dennis Dodd’s take on the matter:
The SEC doesn’t look good as its image as a football-inclined league (at the expense of academics) is enhanced. Ole Miss looks worse. Notice that Vanderbilt, which we all know could use some quarterback help, didn’t, as far as we know, contact Masoli. Neither did Kansas, another school in desperate need of a quarterback.
But at this school, in this league, there is always room for Jeremiah Masolis. (CBSSports.com)
I understand Dodd’s point and I’m not entirely in disagreement with it. With that kind of sentiment floating around, any school that rolled the dice on Masoli was bound to take an image hit.
However, Houston Nutt and his bosses at Ole Miss are more than aware of the baggage that comes with taking in Masoli. If this guy screws up again, some careers will undoubtedly be derailed. Hell, Nutt might find high school coaching jobs hard to come by if Masoli gets arrested again under his watch.
But the burden of dealing with that potential time bomb lies with the Ole Miss athletic department, not the NCAA. That’s because while he’s broken some laws in the past, Masoli’s transfer didn’t break any NCAA rules.
If the NCAA wants to change its tune and make this type of transfer more difficult in the future, then it has every right to do so. But in the meantime, they should go ahead and honor the rules they already have on their books, regardless of how reluctant they are to do so.
*UPDATE* The NCAA finally made a decision this afternoon, Masoli can play football for Ole Miss…in 2011. Strange stuff, man, strange stuff.




Kevin on Wed, 1st Sep 2010 7:19 am
NCAA Denies Jeremiah Masoli’s Waiver
Masoli must sit this year nd they deny his waiver…. he can play next year…
Read this article from ESPN:
http://sports.espn.go.com/ncf/news/story?id=5516909
John Stansberry on Wed, 1st Sep 2010 2:07 pm
@ Kevin - Masoli will never play another down of football. By the time 2011 rolls around, he might very well be in jail for probation violation related to his June arrest. The only reason he bothered to do this was hopefully to play immediately. If he is found guilty of probation violation, Ole Miss will immediately cut him loose.
The NCAA can say this situation violates the “spirit” of the rule, but that’s B.S. So people have to go around interpreting the spirit of rules now? They reinterpreted their own rules on the fly…if they wanted to prevent a graduate transfer of someone who’s been kicked off of a team, they could have written that into the rule to start with.
Kevin on Thu, 2nd Sep 2010 7:11 am
I understand that he not going to play again. I was just correcting your article.
from your article:
*UPDATE* The NCAA finally made a decision this afternoon, Masoli can play football for Ole Miss…in 2011. Strange stuff, man, strange stuff.
Masoli plus Houston Nutt…. Bad situation…
John Stansberry on Thu, 2nd Sep 2010 9:02 am
@ Kevin - I’m still not sure what needs to be corrected, I wrote that he’s cleared to play in 2011, implying his waiver request was denied.